We honestly believe raw ingredients and a hand crafted touch are what makes us who we are. It would be easier to purchase our product, and take much less time, but we LOVE that we are specialty crafted. We give you our best and are honored to be a part of your special day.
To Place an Order:

Email or Call us to place any custom order.


7-10 day notice on orders is suggested, but we do our best to accommodate all last minute calls!

Customized decorated cookies require 10 day notice.

Please inform us of your guest count, event date, and specific questions about an order.

We love inspiration pictures, but please remember, we use these as INSPIRATION, and do not copy cake designs unless explicitly directed to. Tell us what you love, or even hate and we'll be as creative as possible!


We receive numerous inquiries for weekends that we have fully booked, therefore, if any order is canceled, we lose business that has been turned down. For this reason, we require 50% payment on an order cancelled within 48 hours & 100% payment if cancelled within 24 hours.











custom cookie gallery

Looking for a wedding or party favor? Ask us about bagging your cookies for events/gifts!

We have 100s of cutters, give us all your ideas, we'll come up with the best cookie combination for your event! There is no set minimum for quantity of each cookie, but we suggest no less then a total order of 10 cookies. However, we do request a 10 day notice on cookie orders, they are a multiple day, multiple step process and require a lot of detail to make them just perfect :)


Pricing ranges from $3-$6 each. Our bagging charge is $1 per bag or we can sell you our clear cellophane bags for $.25 each


  • Facebook - Grey Circle
  • Twitter - Grey Circle
  • Pinterest - Grey Circle
  • Instagram - Grey Circle
Guilty Bakery

65 Main Street Plymouth, MA 02360

This site was designed with the
website builder. Create your website today.
Start Now
We want 18 pairs of Nike shoes!! #customorder #guiltybakery #decoratedcookies #nike #sneakers #fun