top of page


The Shop



Guilty Bakery was established in 2012 with a dream of combining our love for baking with our passion for creativity. We wanted to create a business driven by the concept that any idea can be brought to life. Flavor and quality will never be compromised.  

Our scratch bakery is where everything is created, from french macarons to whoopie pies, wedding cakes & mini pastries. Our ever changing menu is why our bakery is special. Our flavors vary with the season...or just our cravings that week :)


Our storefront is located in the historic downtown Plymouth area on Main Street. It's the perfect location to stop in for a quick treat and walk around the local shops and waterfront.

We're so excited to expand and open a second storefront in Mashpee Commons!



The brunette.

I started baking with my Mom, the best baker/chef I know. My favorite thing to make was her mother's Whoopie Pies. It wouldn't be a family party if mini whoopie pies weren't there...this very recipe is the one we use on our shop today. My first job was at a Marian's Pie Shop on the Cape, and I was hooked. From there I went to Johnson and Wales, graduated to work at Chatham Bars Inn and eventually became the Executive Pastry Chef at the prestigious Catered Affair in Hingham, where I met Krista. 



The blonde.

Baking wasn't always a part of my childhood. Aside from the occasional family party birthday cake, I didn't expand my dessert horizons past ice cream until I graduated college! I went to school in New York at Wagner College where I played lacrosse and graduated with a degree for English & Teaching.  Soon after, I realized the dream of owning a bakery had to start somewhere & I applied to Le Cordon Bleu Pastry Program where I simultaneously worked and interned under the famous Joanne Chang at Flour Bakery & Cafe in Boston. I completed my internship and took a position at The Catered Affair where I worked with Amy for two years.




We wouldn't be here today without the support of our amazing families and our incredible kids, who are our biggest cheerleaders and ultimate cookie testers.
bottom of page